4 Comments
User's avatar
QC's avatar

YES. i had this realization doing a bio-emotive workshop and it was huge for me ("abused" and "betrayed" were particularly huge for me at the time). the way doug tataryn explained it was something like "feelings are our emotional brain's best understanding of what's happening relationally" or something like that and it unlocked a whole huge thing for me. the NVC pseudo-feeling thing is close to a form of distributed gaslighting tbh

Ivy Mazzola's avatar

Yes! Oof, abused and betrayed are big ones. Distributed gaslighting is definitely how it can play out.

I’m glad I have this post to link to now. It could even be useful from the other end of it, where maybe I’d like to speak this way (percieved action as feeling), but I can tell they aren’t actually stepping into their body to figure out what that means. But there is so much information to dig into right there, so efficiently!

Sasha Chapin's avatar

I completely agree with this. I also feel that NVC's attempt to police feelings vs. pseudo-feelings is an example of missing the point: if wholesome intent is established, saying "I feel abandoned" will be heard just fine.

Ivy Mazzola's avatar

Definitely! I think NVC expects you to start communicating regardless of what intent you and your partner are feeling. You've got to start somewhere, but that's a slow and laborious way to do it, to dredge up "wholesome intent" from the subconscious somewhere along the way, rather than setting the stage with it.